Changes between Version 9 and Version 10 of faq/email/avoid-forward


Ignore:
Timestamp:
Apr 19, 2022, 12:51:14 PM (3 years ago)
Author:
Jamie McClelland
Comment:

--

Legend:

Unmodified
Added
Removed
Modified
  • faq/email/avoid-forward

    v9 v10  
    11[[TranslatedPages]]
    2 == What's wrong with forwarding my email to another provider? ==
     2= Please don't forward your email to another provider =
    33
    44Our servers are configured so that, if you want, you can forward email sent to your email account on our servers to an email address on a different server, such as `gmail.com`.
     
    88It's also understandable to desire one email program that shows all of our email messages, even ones sent to different email addresses. Who wants to login to multiple web mail programs?
    99
     10== The Problem ==
     11
    1012The problem is that forwarding your email from one address to another is not a good technical solution to this problem and there are a few reasons why:
    1113
    12  * unlike most email providers, May First takes a strong stance against censorship. If you forward your email, we will forward ''all'' the email to the destination address. Other email providers, who have spam policies that will block all messages from servers that they think are spammers, detect that we are sending spam and will block us from delivering your email. In other words, they will refuse to delivery ''any'' email, including legitimate email, because some of the email being sent is spam.
    13  * in an effort to stop fake email messages, many providers advertise to the world which servers should be allowed to send email that claims to be from their domain name. For example, if an email claims to be from an @yahoo.co or @gmail.com address, then it ''must'' be sent from a Yahoo or Gmail server. However, if someone sends a message from a @yahoo.com or @gmail.com address to your May First account, and then ''our'' server forwards it to another provider, that provider will detect that it was ''not'' sent by Yahoo and Gmail. And, it will not get delivered.
     14 * **Authentication problems**: In an effort to stop fake email messages, many providers advertise to the world which servers should be allowed to send email that claims to be from their domain name. For example, if an email claims to be from an `@yahoo.com` or `@gmail.com` address, then it ''must'' be sent from a Yahoo or Gmail server. However, if someone sends a message from a `@yahoo.com` or `@gmail.com` address to your May First account, and then ''our'' server forwards it to another provider, that provider will detect that it was ''not'' sent by Yahoo and Gmail. And, it will not get delivered.
     15 * **May First gets tagged as a spammer**: If you forward your email, we will forward ''all'' the email to the destination address. Other email providers, who have spam policies that will block all messages from servers that they think are spammers, detect that we are sending spam and will block us from delivering your email. In other words, they will refuse to delivery ''any'' email, including legitimate email, because some of the email being sent is spam.
     16 
     17== The Solution ==
    1418
    1519The best solution to this problem is to have email delivered to your May First accounts, rather than forwarding your email to another email address ([wiki:add_email_address_to_account directions for creating email accounts]).
     
    2125Please use this method! It will ensure that you receive all of your email, it will avoid having our servers blocked by anyone, and it will guarantee that your email, at least in the initial delivery, is being handled by a provider politically sensitive to your mission.
    2226
    23 Before ending this FAQ, since `gmail.com` was named above, the question remains: why use Google at all? Why support their corporate/ad-focused model? May First/People Link supports two webmail programs (Roundcube and Horde/Imp) and supports a number of desktop email clients (see [wiki:faq/email/configure-email directions for configuring email clients]). By using these tools instead of Google you are investing your time and energy into a community the revolves around free software and progressive politics rather than building a community that revolves around turning your emails, searches, videos watched and web browsing habits into a commodity that is sold to advertisers, and most likely openly shared with governments.
     27Before ending this FAQ, since `gmail.com` was named above, the question remains: why use Google at all? Why support their corporate/ad-focused model? May First supports an [https://roundcube.mayfirst.org: excellent webmail program] and supports a number of desktop email clients (see [wiki:faq/email/configure-email directions for configuring email clients]).
     28
     29By using these tools instead of Google you are investing your time and energy into a community the revolves around free software and progressive politics rather than building a community that revolves around turning your emails, searches, videos watched and web browsing habits into a commodity that is sold to advertisers, and most likely openly shared with governments.